A former senior CIA officer has emphasized the critical need for the United States to cultivate a significantly stronger relationship with India, citing compatible interests and shared democratic values. James C. Lawler, formerly the head of the CIA’s Counter-Proliferation Division, expressed his long-held bewilderment at the historically complex and sometimes distant nature of Indo-US relations. Despite periods of turbulence, he believes the two nations have more in common than not, highlighting vibrant economies and a substantial Indian diaspora contributing to American society.
Lawler articulated that both countries, being democracies with converging economic aspirations, should move beyond a standoffish posture. He noted India’s shift towards capitalism as a factor that could foster deeper collaboration. The former intelligence official, who has never visited India, expressed a keen desire to do so.
His comments arrive amid evolving India-US relations, particularly during the Trump administration. The imposition of tariffs and disputes over India’s energy imports from Russia created friction. While the US claimed assurances were given regarding Russian oil purchases, India has consistently maintained its right to independent foreign policy. Lawler acknowledged past hesitations in the relationship, partly attributed to India’s historical ties with the Soviet Union and its reliance on Russian military hardware. He advocated for increased technology sharing with India.
Addressing contemporary geopolitical challenges, Lawler pointed to shared strategic concerns, particularly regarding China. He urged a departure from Cold War-era thinking, advocating for the exploration of mutual interests to build a more robust partnership. The former officer believes that by working together, both nations can achieve greater collective strength.